Book Review: Through the Shadowlands

Julie Rehmeyer is a science writer and person with ME who has written extensively about research and controversies like the PACE trial. But today, she publishes Through the Shadowlands, a book about her personal journey through ME and back to life.

I have read this book from two perspectives. First, I had the opportunity to read Julie’s early drafts and provide feedback as her friend. But before publication, I was able to read the final version from start to finish with the perspective of a reviewer, and I offer my comments here.

The first thing to know about this book is that Julie can write. She tells her story with honesty and clarity, and the narrative tugs the reader along her winding path from childhood through illness and on to the other side. Julie can explain facts and details so clearly, and then write passages like, “The straw of my house gleamed golden against the brown patches of mud plaster, as if the house were the love child of the sun and the earth.” The experience of reading this book is a pleasure.

Julie’s story of getting sick, and how her life began to shrink, will feel very familiar to people with ME. She describes knowing, “Something is really, really wrong with me.” We’ve all had that moment – before diagnosis, perhaps even before seeking medical care. Each of us has that point of recognition that our bodies have shifted out of health in a serious and fundamental way. And Julie entered the same labyrinth that so many of us did: the trips to different doctors, the suggestion or diagnosis of a psychological problem, the lack of scientifically established treatments. She faced victim blaming, where someone insists that if the suggested treatment didn’t work then she must not be trying hard enough, or must not want to get well. We’ve all been there.

But Julie isn’t just talking to ME patients with this book. In fact, I think she is talking primarily to people not familiar with ME. That audience will feel, along with Julie, what this is like. She writes, “I tried to explain that running off after every quack treatment my friends pushed on me just made me feel desperate and hopeless. The reality was that nobody knew what to do about this fucking disease — if they did, I would have heard about it by then.” I wish I could have been so clear with the dozens upon dozens of people who have tried to push answers on me over the years.

Despite choosing to accept her reality, Julie does not stop looking for answers and rejecting ideas that do not make sense to her. Supplements are a way to part the “gullible” from their money. She found people who wore magnets in their underwear or relied on homeopathy or wore devices that zapped electricity through the wrist. But other ideas do not sound so strange to her, like a shamanic journey or mold avoidance or consulting a psychic.

And this will be one of the challenging parts of Julie’s story for people to accept. Realizing that science was not going to provide her with answers, she decided to try a “Hail Mary pass” and test whether mold was making her sick. She chose mold based on her intuition. For some reason she cannot articulate, trying mold avoidance felt right when magnets and supplements sounded wrong.

After spending two weeks in the desert, Julie finds that she does react immediately and strongly to mold (or something else in the environment). And showers bring near instant relief from the worst of the symptoms. Over and over, she experiences sudden, crippling attacks and is restored by showers or other decontamination methods. Julie deftly explains the science behind mold reactivity (while noting that so much more science is needed), and theories for why her reaction could be so severe and resolve so dramatically. There is no proof beyond her self-experimentation, but there can be no denying that this is true for her.

Julie’s mold avoidance actually increases her sensitivity, and the severity of her reactions. There are a number of frightening episodes, but she clings to the fullness of life as she navigates through them. Despite her illness, Julie resumes her career, meets a new man, and travels internationally. I think she shows extraordinary courage, living her life and trusting that she will be able to handle whatever the illness throws at her.

One of the remarkable things about Julie’s story is the way she balances seemingly inconsistent points of view. She tackles mold avoidance scientifically, but also holds herself open to emotional and spiritual approaches. She is constantly questioning herself and her interpretations of her experiences. Julie is willing to try things, even if they sound a little wacky, and then thoughtfully integrate what she learns. This is an extraordinarily difficult thing to do, and even more difficult to explain well. Julie does both. Through experimentation, Julie is able to reduce her reactivity to mold and regain much functionality. She is not cured, but she is much improved.

Mold avoidance is controversial, both inside and outside the ME community. And Julie is clear that, “My experience obviously does not establish that ME/CFS as a whole is caused by mold or related contaminants, and I strongly doubt that’s true. Accurately assessing how many ME/CFS patients are affected by mold is impossible at this point.” Julie is simultaneously adamant that there is a scientific basis to mold sensitivity, and that much more science and funding is needed to find answers for all ME patients.

Through the Shadowlands speaks an important truth to the world. Julie tells the truth about what it is like to live with ME in ways that patients will identify with and that outsiders will understand. She makes the case for why current medical care and PACE-like models are atrociously bad. And Julie’s determination to seize life to her fullest ability is an example of courage to everyone.

My favorite parts of Through the Shadowlands are the passages where Julie describes her connection to the earth. I have always felt a deep well of connection to nature, and I recognize the same in Julie’s description of her time in Death Valley:

I felt myself expand into this great space, this emptiness. Despite the wind’s immense swirl of energy, the land felt, quiet, still, impassive. Everything fell away from me — my body, my pain and exhaustion, my fear, my strange experiment — and was replaced with a huge and ancient stillness. All the time, I thought, this place was here, whether I was pinned to my bed or bounding up a mountain trail. As I poured out into the valley, I felt the valley pouring into me, its enormous spaciousness filling my chest.

Through the Shadowlands is an honest and moving account of what it is like to have ME, and to live a real life with it. In my opinion, both the ME community and those who have never heard of us can learn something from Julie’s story.

This entry was posted in Commentary and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Book Review: Through the Shadowlands

  1. This book is a must read for those experiencing debilitating illness after mold exposure and for their loved ones who can’t understand why they are so sick. Through her personal memoir Julie paints a vivid picture of what it’s like for thousands of environmentally disabled people who can get no help from misinformed physicians. The book exposes the U.S. government backed science fraud which falsely claims to prove that symptoms such as Julie’s cannot be caused by mold exposure. It’s the continuing gov’t backed and funded fraud in physician education, more so than the mold itself, that causes continuing harm to so many. Kudos to Julie! She has done a beautiful job of expertly telling this true tale that desperately needed to be told.

  2. Karen Scott says:

    Thank you for your thoughtful, balanced review. I prepurchased the book and was notified that it was available in iBooks yesterday. I began to read it yesterday. Julie is a good writer and it will not be a chore to read this book. In fact, it should be a pleasure.

  3. kathy d. says:

    I have been curious about Julie Rehmeyer’s book since I read an article by her debunking the Pace trial and then the op-ed she and David Tuller had published in the NY Times about the same thing.
    I have put this book on library reserve. Can’t wait to read it.

  4. jimells says:

    I don’t know why mold should be controversial. A quick search of Pubmed on the phrase “mast cell activation and fungi” yields 500 articles. The more I learn about mast cells, the more convinced I am that mast cells play an important role for a subset of ME patients.

    Of course, convincing doctors to seriously consider the idea of mast cells is a chore in itself, since the guidelines insist that without a rash there can be no mast cell issue, in spite of research showing that half of mast cell patients have no rash [1].

    The question I have is, why has the ME community completely missed the boat on possible mast cell problems?

    [1] “Often seen, rarely recognized: mast cell activation disease–a guide to diagnosis and therapeutic options.”

    Also see:
    “Hyperadrenergic postural tachycardia syndrome in mast cell activation disorders.”

    “The role of mast cells in functional GI disorders.”

    • Jennie Spotila says:

      Mast cells have been in play for awhile. I’ve discussed it with my own doctor, and I know a number of patients pursuing it. I’ve heard at least one conference presentation on it.

  5. Heather says:

    Can’t wait to read!

  6. Viral Nomaly says:

    Before reading the whole story, I love to read reviews. It was nice that your taking time to share this with us. It actually makes me curious.

Comments are closed.